One of these, not being master of him, is carried to an altogether
different world acquired as a fruit of his Karman. This other person is merely conjoined
with the sin of one who commits suicide. If the person survives, he or she can do much
good to the deceased and to him self or herself by offering water etc. (to the spirit);
but, if the person dies, he or she can do good to neither". 62
The above is one of the most interesting passages in Sanskrit
literature: it supplies us with contemporary evidence on the subject under discussion. It
throws a flood of light upon the period when it was written. The first and foremost point
that strikes us on reading it is that it was not merely the self-annihilation of the widow
but a general annihilation of persons or things related to the dead person, known as
Anumarana.
It was this custom that was prevalent when Bana wrote. It was not
merely the case of a woman following her dead husband as Sati, but that on the demise of a
father, brother, friend, his sorts or daughters, his brothers or sisters, and his or her
friends, immolated themselves. Such a thing is unheard-of, and no instance of it is known
from any kind of Indian literature, secular or sacred, prior to the time of Bana.
Instances of this general Anumarana are by no means lacking in
inscriptions and chronicles of a later period. But it can be asserted, without any fear of
contradiction, that such a custom was unknown to India before Bana
flourished. The second
point that has to be recorded is that Bana passes the same verdict on this
Anumarana as
has been passed by Medhatithi, viz. that it is an act of suicide.
Thirdly, Bana asserts in the most unambiguous terms that this
immolation does no good at all to the person concerned, Whose destination is already
determined by his Karman, while living on earth. In the law-codes, however, it is the
Vishnu Smriti that sanctions widow burning, for the first time in the religious and legal
literature of India. The Vishnu Smriti has been supposed, to have been compiled soon
after the 5th century A.D. We have now to see if there is any epigraphic evidence shedding
light on the subject.