The Viramitrodaya is in substantial agreement with the theory of the
Mayukha. The Vivadatandava is against the narrow views of the Bengal school, whereas the
Smrtichandrika states that the mother inherits whatever property will be counted as the
Adhyagnika. The Dayabhaga, though giving absolute power to a woman over Stridhana does not
enumerate the kinds of property, but only excludes certain kinds. Katyayana, however,
definitely lists what kinds of property cannot be included in Stridhana. The property
acquired by a woman by mechanical arts or given through affection by a stranger is to be
excluded from Stridhana. The properties given to a woman at certain times, under certain
conditions, as ornaments to be worn on festive occasions, or with a, fraudulent design,
e.g., in order to cheat coparceners of their share of certain property under pretence that
it had been given to a daughter, are to be excluded from it, and he limits the amount of
Stridhana, in that it should not exceed two thousand annas in value, and all the immovable
property cannot be included in it.58 This limitation of the amount of Stridhana is in
substantial agreement with the views of Kautilya.
Thus in almost all the commentaries and digests the word Stridhana came
to be used in a restricted sense, and did not cover the entire property of a woman. The
inherited property and the immovable property are not under her full dominion. The husband
shares the right with her. The Mitakshara states clearly that the husband can use the
Stridhana under certain circumstances.
This notion was probably based and was developed on the texts of law
codes avowing perpetual tutelage of women. Vijnanesvara states it clearly: 'Before
marriage the father shall restrain a woman from wickedness, and after it the husband,
failing him the sons, and in her old age the said relatives being deficient, the distant
kinsmen; on failure of any relatives, the king, according to the text. If both the husband
and father's races are extinct, let the king be the protector and guardian of a woman.
Therefore women are not independent at anytime'. 59