Discourses On Gita By Acharya Vinoba Bhave 
Major Sections
Discourses On Gita
BHAKTI : SAGUNA AND NIRGUNA
 
The saguna devotee and the nirguna devotee - both children of the same mother

3. Now, in the Twelfth Chapter we come to the end of the treatment of the philosophy of bhakti. Arjuna
questioned the Lord here about the perfect state, as once before in the Fifth Chapter he questioned Him at the end of the discussion about the philosophy of life. Arjuna asks, "Lord, some worship you as saguna, with form, others as nirguna, without form. Tell me which of the two pleases you more." 

4. What answer could the Lord give? This is like asking a mother to choose between her two sons. One of the two is a little child, who clings to his mother, who is filled with joy at sight of his mother, and cries when he is parted from her even for a moment. Without her the world seems empty to him. This is the younger son. The other son is older. He too loves his mother dearly, but he has grown up and has reached the age of discretion. 

He can bear to stay away from his mother. Even if he has to stay away from her for five or six months, he would not mind it. He serves his mother, taking full responsibility on himself. Because he is busy with his work, he is able to endure separation from her. He is respected by the world, and his mother is happy listening to people speaking highly of him. That is the elder son.

Back ] Vinoba Bhave ] Up ] Next ]

About Bhakti  : Saguna And Nirguna
From one pointedness.Pg1 
From one pointedness.Pg2 
From one pointedness.Pg3
The saguna devotee...Pg1
The saguna devotee...Pg2
The saguna devotee...Pg3
The saguna devotee...Pg4
Saguna is easy and safe.Pg1
Saguna is easy and safe.Pg2
Saguna is easy and safe.Pg3
Saguna is easy and safe.Pg4
Without nirguna ....Pg1
Without nirguna ....Pg2
Without nirguna ....Pg3
The two are complementary.Pg1
The two are complementary.Pg2
The two are complementary.Pg3
The two are complementary.Pg4
The two are complementary.Pg5
An example from the....Pg1
An example from the....Pg2
An example from the....Pg3
Personal experience
Therefore let us attain....Pg1
Therefore let us attain....Pg2